Chris Skinner's blog

Shaping the future of finance

My friends attack Gartner over MiFID

Chris Skinner Author Avatar
by

Some of you know that I've spent a while looking at MiFID.  In fact, I'm so sad that I even produced a book about it ... there you go.

So
some might think I'd know a little about the subject, although not
nearly as much as my friends in the MiFID Community on the buy and sell
side who enjoy sharing ideas with me, even if they don't want to
publicly state those ideas. 

They're all up in arms now though
after the rip-roaring mirth created over the latest gaff from an
analyst who hasn't spent enough time understanding the market or,
conversely, just doesn't understand the market.

The firm in
question is Gartner, who I have to say I respect for their Magic
Quadrants and numbers for hardware sales forecasts but, when it comes
to vertical market analysis, some might say they are vertically
challenged.

Here's an example: Gartner says MiFID will only be a small IT update for most UK firms, a report from Friday's Computer Weekly.

"For the majority it (MiFID) is a small update to what they have in place and some can  be outsourced."

These are the words of one Peter Redshaw, research director at Gartner. 

Now, I know that Europe's largest market making firms have spent over €100 million each this year on MiFID, so that's what Gartner call a small update?

He goes on to say things like:

"In the UK, businesses are probably doing ok because the UK already has a lot of MiFID requirements as de-facto."

So that's why the European Commission,
the FSA, the Treasury, and various groups from MiFID-Connect to the
Joint Working Group have spent three years collaborating to produce
ranges of consultation papers and new regulatory advice, with massive
changes to operations, processes and systems for all buy and sell side
firms affected.

"Features of MiFID that Redshaw
said the UK is already prepeared for include best execution when a
customer must be given the best deal available. 'Companies are already
used to searching for the best price,' said Redshaw."

So that's why CESR, the FSA, AMF, BaFIN and the rest have been arguing about how to define best execution and we still don't have a clear answer.

No wonder my friends are laughing.

First comment from a leading expert I know on MiFID and one of London's leading MiFID advisors:

"Just
so you are aware of the rubbish being heaped upon the unwashed at the
moment … I translate this as: 'We can’t figure it out and don’t care
what the industry that spends the most money on the face of the planet
on technology think'."

Second comment from one of the leading
thinkers around MiFID and a man who has capital markets flowing through
his blood and veins:

"This is too vertical and granular for Gartner, hence if they don’t understand it, they sandbag."

I
guess for an industry that is spending millions on a Directive that
they didn't ask for, which has great ambiguities, stepping into the
fray with an unguarded comment goes down pretty badly.

So, I'll
just stick with saying that: "Best Execution has the clarity required
to ensure that no firm will be confused by what it means" ...

... why are those men in the white coats coming into the office?

 

RegulationCategories
Chris Skinner Author Avatar

Chris M Skinner

Chris Skinner is best known as an independent commentator on the financial markets through his blog, TheFinanser.com, as author of the bestselling book Digital Bank, and Chair of the European networking forum the Financial Services Club. He has been voted one of the most influential people in banking by The Financial Brand (as well as one of the best blogs), a FinTech Titan (Next Bank), one of the Fintech Leaders you need to follow (City AM, Deluxe and Jax Finance), as well as one of the Top 40 most influential people in financial technology by the Wall Street Journal's Financial News. To learn more click here...

Intelligent Money: Our Future Is Where We Do Not Think About Money, As Our Money Thinks For Us

What is the future?

Learn more

Learn more about Chris

About Chris Skinner

The Past, Present And Future Of Banking, Finance And Technology

Fintech expert Chris Skinner: countries need digital transformation to remain competitive

Join me on Linkedin

Follow Me on X!

Hire Chris Skinner for dinners, workshops and more

Learn directly from from one of the most influential people in technology, gain insights from the world's most innovative companies, and build a global network.

Chris’s latest book

Order now

Chris Skinner’s ‘Intelligent Money’ Book Launch Event

Top 50 Global Thought Leaders and Influencers on Finance 2024

Global Awards

Lifetime Achievement Award

Global 100 - 2024 Winner

Chris Skinner - Financial Markets Advisor of the Year - The Finanser - UK 2023

Best Financial Markets Advisor of the Year 2023

30 Best Regtech Blogs and Websites 2023

Kids creating the future bank | TEDxAthens

Captain Cake and the Candy Crew

Captain Cake Winner of a Golden Mom’s Choice Award

TWO-TIME WINNER OF A MOM’S CHOICE GOLD AWARD!

Alex at the Financial Services

Gaping Void's Hugh MacLeod worked with the Finanser