So I had a meeting the other day where we started arguing about banks and what banks really are these days.
The traditional view is that banks are those that offer deposit accounts and have a bank licence. They are recognised by regulators as banks, and governments oversee their activities.
That view is no longer valid however, as we have a lot of other things that are like banks around.
I define them as Near Banks, Like Banks and New Banks, although I’m sure you could have your own definitions and views.
Near Banks are institutions that have been around for a long time working with the banks, and are now offering semi-direct services to consumers and corporates as part of their offers. This is the Visa, MasterCard, VocaLink and BKM’s http://thefinanser.co.uk/fsclub/2014/08/bkm-turkey.html of this world. These institutions have worked as bank service providers for decades, and often were owned by the banks but, in this increasingly competitive world, are now commercial entities spun out of the system. In most cases, they still work with the banks but, give it a few years, and these providers may well be in a competitive position with their founders due to the demands of the markets.
Like Banks are exactly that: they are just like banks except they are not banks. In this category, I would place Moven, Simple, Holvi, Google, Facebook, Apple and more. For all intensive purposes, they offer the capabilities to do everything you can do with a traditional bank, except that they do not hold a bank licence themselves. Most of these providers offer these bank-like services by front-ending a bank as a wrap-around although, in the case of Holvi, they take it a step further by gaining a payments licence. That proves interesting in that, like PayPal, if you have a payments licence or emoney licence, you can pretty much operate as though you are a bank, even though you are not.
Finally, we come to my favourite category: New Banks. It is my favourite as this category really is the mover and shaker, rather than the Great Pretender. Y’see, the Like Banks aren’t banks but pretend to be one whilst the New Banks aren’t banks and don’t try to be one. They are New Banks, completely different to anything that’s gone before. A great example is Zopa, a lending service that has created a new model of enabling investing and borrowing. Others include Kickstarter, Indiegogo, Funding Circle, the House Crowd. These are all pooling crowd funding into new forms of finance or, if you prefer, new banking services.
The challenge within all of this is therefore to work out what is a bank? Is it a bank with a licence, a processor with a licence, a brand with a bank partner or a platform enabling new transactions and money flows?
I’ll let you decide, even though I haven’t even mentioned bitcoin or cryptocurrencies yet …