
I was reading four stories about cryptocurrency this morning and realised that they are all connected. They tell us something about the evolution of money and, more importantly, the evolution of crime.
The first is about FaceStealer, a North Korean hacking operation exposed by the FBI. Using fake Zoom and Microsoft Teams meetings, webcam footage and impersonation, the criminals stole more than $400 million and impersonated over 900 people in just eighteen months. These are not naïve consumers. They are cryptocurrency executives, developers and cybersecurity experts.
The second is that the US government, working with the private sector, has helped freeze $2.7 billion of the more than $6 billion stolen from Binance by the very same North Korean hackers. Isn't it slightly ironic that a financial system designed to operate independently of governments needs governments to protect its money?
The third is that cryptocurrency journalism is increasingly being automated. Press Gazette reports on seemingly fictitious journalists with fabricated professional credentials, which means that you are investing in digital assets based upon information provided by digital personalities who don't exist. What could go wrong?
The fourth, and most disturbing, is the rise of something called wrenching. Why spend months trying to break sophisticated encryption when you can threaten someone with a wrench and force them to hand over their passwords? Reported attacks are up 33% this year, with losses of $124 million, and involve kidnapping, home invasions and threats against families.
This last story particularly strikes me because it brings us full circle.
We have spent centuries moving money out of our homes and into institutions because we don't want criminals turning up at our front doors demanding our wealth. Now, having spent billions developing sophisticated technologies to remove those institutions, we are bringing that risk back into our homes.
Remember the cryptocurrency mantra: not your keys, not your coins?
You lose your private keys you lose the money but, then again, if someone is holding a gun to your child's head, whose keys do you think they are?
This is where the debate about cryptocurrency gets interesting.
A blockchain can verify a transaction but it cannot verify whether the person authorising that transaction is doing so willingly. It can prove that someone controls a private key, but it cannot prove that they are the rightful owner of that key. It can record the movement of money, but it cannot determine whether that movement constitutes a payment or a crime.
These are not problems of cryptography. They are problems of humanity, and they explain why finance has evolved around institutions, laws, regulation, insurance and systems of redress.
We often confuse trust in technology with trust in people. They are two very different things.
The great promise of cryptocurrency was that we could remove the trusted third party from finance. The great irony is that, when something goes wrong, the first thing we look for is a trusted third party. In other words, the weakest link in the blockchain is the human being at either end of it.
For more information:
FaceStealer Cryptocurrency Theft Scheme — FBI
U.S. Helps Freeze $2.7 Billion Stolen in Binance Cryptocurrency Heist
Bots are replacing reporters in cryptocurrency journalism
Wrench attack warning: Surging violent crime trend targeting crypto owners
Chris M Skinner
Chris Skinner is best known as an independent commentator on the financial markets through his blog, TheFinanser.com, as author of the bestselling book Digital Bank, and Chair of the European networking forum the Financial Services Club. He has been voted one of the most influential people in banking by The Financial Brand (as well as one of the best blogs), a FinTech Titan (Next Bank), one of the Fintech Leaders you need to follow (City AM, Deluxe and Jax Finance), as well as one of the Top 40 most influential people in financial technology by the Wall Street Journal's Financial News. To learn more click here...